My review when this appeared last year:
- “Kelly volunteers that for this story he is standing on the shoulders of the giants Cordwainer Smith and Alfred Bester. The story starts far, far future, with a seriously post-modern genmod human called Mada, fleeing across multi-dimensional multi-chronological space. The ship’s AI (actually a DI – Dependent Intelligence) is a bit of a wuss, panicking because the chasing Utopians have put an identity mine five minutes downwhen of them. Desperate situations call for desperate measures, and Mada’s evasive action is quite dramatic : jumping to the even further far future (two 10th of a galactic spin). Mada makes her way to humanity’s homeworld, and finds it a strange, sparsely populated place. The contrast in this second half of the story to the first is sharp. The story slips close (albeit with the rider about Kelly doffing his virtual plume-ed cap to Cordwainer Smith/Alfred Bester) to a faux-Medieval cod-pastoral idyll.She decides to re-populate the planet (and *that* genmod transformation is a real treat) and re-start humanity on its way to the stars. In the climax Mada makes a major personal choice.An enjoyable story, well-written and inventive. In previous reviews I have bemoaned the Eleanor Arnason ‘Lydia Duluth’ stories for lack of invention – I would use this story to exemplify what I think good SF is about : more ideas in a couple of pages than a tranche of Lydia Duluth stories.”
I read the original in the Peanutpress version on my PDA, and only found out some time later that the print version used back-to-front narrative to ‘rewind’ the action whenever Mada when back in time (‘skipping downwhen’). This simple technique does in fact add a lot to the story.
Michael Blumlein. Know How, Can Do.
Originally in Fantasy & Science Fiction Dec 2001.
When originally I reviewed this, I spake thus:
- In the last Blumlein story from F&SF (‘Paul and Me’, collected in the 50th anniversary F&SF volume), we had Paul Bunyan in a homosexual relationship which proved true the adage that size doesn’t matter. ROTFL. “Here we have a story where the main character is somewhat smaller – a humble worm. Well, a worm that is no longer humble – for the worm in question is a research lab worm who has been genomically crafted to a human brain and ergo can think. I think, therefore I am, is the fundamental premise of the worm’s existence, and we get a true worm’s eye view of his perspective on life. One of those stories you will either love or hate. I loved it. “
Richard Wadholm. From Here You Can See the Sunquists.
Originally in Asimovs, January 2001.
An once again, my original comment:
- “The quality of the fiction in this issue remains high (following Robert Reed’s ‘Mirror’) with Richard Wadholm’s From Here You Can See the Sunquists covers similar ground in some respects. A couple visit La Jete, a holiday resort which enables holidaymakers to travel back in time. The Sunquists have visited before, and they once again look back fondly on their courting days and earlier lives. The vicarious nature of this, and particularly the slightly less than appealing Mr. Sunquist suggest that this is one holiday that will not be fondly remembered. A wrong turning and a visit to the future show more than either Mr. or Mrs. Sunquist really want to see.”
Robin Wayne Bailey. Keepers of the Earth.
Originally in Silicon Dreams.
The first in the volume which I hadn’t read. Humanity has fled Earth, leaving it a charred cinder. Over the millenia a single robot builds others, who themselves build others, and nanobit by nanobit Earth is returned to its former glory. But when humans look to return, how will the robots welcome them?
The story felt a little ‘retro’, more in keeping with golden age SF than contemporary SF. A nice read, but not brilliant.
Gregory Benford. Anomalies.
Originally in Redshift.
The moon is found to have shifted ahead of its orbit. The scientists of the world are bemused, until one suggests an explanation. The nature of the explanation, and its implications for the future of Earth are worrying.
Ian Watson. One of Her Paths.
Originally in F&SF Oct/Nov 2001.
My words of wisdom upon reading it last year:
- “Now this is more like it! (The previous stories had been less than brilliant).
Tau Ceti is the destination for the first crewed starship, Pioneer, using the new Q-drive to undertake a journey through probability space.
Allen Steele’s ‘Coyote’ series has over the past year in Asimovs been taking us through a deep space colonisation tale, but this at once is different.
Written in the present tense (present imperfect I think, but grammar was never my strong point) is a little unsettling, and feels perhaps gimmicky. We see the journey through the eyes of Dr Mary Nolan, and until the crew members strap themselves in for the leap through ‘probability space’ everything is pretty much as you would expect.
The quantum nature of the vessel impacts in a huge way when Q-insertion takes place. Dr Nolan finds herself alone in the ship. The infinite variations of quantum science has meant that there now a multitude of individual Probe’s, and she faces six months alone before the ship drops out of Q-space.
Whereas in Steele’s Coyote series one crew member unfrozen in the course of the journey goes barking mad, Dr Nolan very much becomes one with herself, and with a larger ‘something’.
When the ship is re-combined in normal space, the crew are brought back together. However, one pregnant crew member has given birth, and the child is very much different.
The question of whether we are alone, individually, and as a race, and the nature of time and reality and perception are explored (much better than Steele story in which duty rosters and Minutes of Meeting are provided!) And the story being written in the present tense falls into place, giving the story a sense of actually happening now.”
Michael Swanwick. The Dog Said Bow-Wow.
Originally in Asimovs Oct/Nov 2001.
And once more to the original review:
- “As you will now if you have been reading my reviews for some time, humour in SF is not one of my favourite reading matters – primarily because a lot of SF humour is so rarely funny. Swanwick proves that it can be done, in a wonderfully bizarre/baroque sort of futuristic-steampunk-ishy way. Sir Blackthorpe Ravenscairn de Plus Precieux is an upright, walking, talking dog of some class, who falls in with a rum sort of cove when visiting London. A plot is hatched in which the very heart of the English monarch (a gross, maggot like Queen, symbolising, perhaps….) is threatened. Gads sir, a palpable hit! “
Nancy Kress. And No Such Things Grow Here.
Originally in Asimovs June 2001.
My original review stated:
- “Ecological problems caused by GM food and Global Warming have given rise to a most uncomfortable environment, few cars, and a groundswell against GM and related matters. So when her sister Perri is arrested on a GM felony and banged up in Riker’s island, Dee has to use her police training to find the Mr Big whom is the real guilty party. Joining an eco-terrorist group gives Dee some insight into the GM dabate, but it is not as clear cut as she thought.One quibble: the attempt on her life is laughable!”
Whilst I only gave one quibble in the review, I didn’t make a point of praising the story, and I would certainly rank it below stories in the same throbbing issue such as Charles Stross’ ‘Lobsters’ and Andy Duncan’s ‘The Chief Designer’!
Stephen Baxter. Sun-Cloud.
Originally in Starlight #3.
Baxter once more gets into the mind of a non-human being. In this case a far-future creature of minute proportions, who manipulates time its very self to find an answer to the biggest questions.
Jim Grimsley. Into Greenwood.
Originally in Asimovs Sept 2001.
My review last year:
- “The water-surrounded forest of Greenwood is populated by sentient trees who have developed bizzare mutually symbiotic relationships with individual humans who genmod themselves to become almost as one with an individual tree. The protagonist is seeking her brother Binam, who chose to become a sym as a child. Through him she finally makes contact with the groupmind of the forest and comes to an arrangement regarding their joint desire for freedom. In doing so, however, she reveals more about the nature of the tree/human symbiotic relationship than was known previously. As appears to be de rigeur nowadays there is an (albeit minor) lesbian episode.For me the story didn’t really manage to engage me with the characters, who were pretty much there to carry the plot and the concept along.”
Not a story which I would have put forward for a Top 11 of the year!
Dan Simmons. On K2 with Kanakaredes.
Originally in Redshift.
There have been several mountaineering stories over the years, and in this one an extra-terrestial from the race known as ‘The Listeners’ joins a climb up the dangerous K2. In the process of the climb and the fatal descent, more is learnt about the aliens and the humans. Neatly told, but not earth-shattering.
So – what to make of Silverberg’s entry into the year’s best anthology market?
Firstly, praise for getting the book out so quickly! Although there are some reservations as to what this means for the collection policy. Certainly the December 2001 issues of Asimovs, F&SF and Analog will have been within the frame for choosing stories. But the December issue of Interzone?
Secondly, the book is deceptively chunky (almost 500 pages), but there aren’t that many words on each page! And the margins of the pages go quite close to the spine, requiring the book to spread quite worryingly wide to read to the end of the line on left-hand pages, and the beginning of the line on right-hand pages.
Thirdly, in terms of sources – Asimovs, F&SF and Analog are well represented. Interzone and Spectrum SF aren’t at all – which is particularly galling as Ian R. Macleod’s ‘Isabel of the Fall’ from Interzone is a glaring omission IMHO.
Fourthly, in terms of stories – I would certainly agree with seven out of eleven of the stories. However, for me the Bailey, Benford, Kress, and Grimsley would be behind any of the following!
- Lucius Shepard’s ‘Eternity’ (F&SF March 2001)
- Robert Reed’s ‘Market Day (F&SF March 2001)
- Geoff Ryman’s ‘Have Not Have’ (F&SF April 2001)
- Charles Stross’ ‘Lobsters’ (Asimovs June 2001)
- Andy Duncan’s ‘The Chief Designer’ (Asimvos June 2001)
- Robert Charles Wilson’s ‘The Great Goodbye'(Asimovs Aug 2001)
- Eliot Fintushel’s ‘Female Action’ (Asimovs Oct 2001)
- Charles Stross’ ‘Troubador’ (Asimovs Nov 2001)
- Simon Ings’ ‘Menage’ (Asimovs Nov 2001)
- Tony Ballantyne’s ‘Restoring the Balance’ (Interzone May 2001)
- Paul di Filippo’s ‘Babylon Sisters’ (Interzone June 2001)
- Ian R. Macleod’s ‘Isabel of the Fall’ (Interzone July 2001)
- Ruaridh Pringle’s ‘Meeting the Relatives’ (Interzone Sept 2001)
- James Lovergrove’s ‘Junk Male’ (Interzone Sept 2001)
- Spectrum SF:
- Eric Brown’s ‘Instructions for Surviving the Destruction of Star-Probe X-11-57’ (#6, July 2001),
- David Redd’s ‘Green England’ (#7, Nov 2001)
- George Zebrowski’s ‘Augi’ (Analog Jan 2001)
- Bud Sparhawk’s ‘Magic’s Price’ (Analog March 2001)
- Brian Stableford’s ‘The Milk of Human Kindness’ (Analog March 2001)
- Shane Tourtellotte’s ‘The Return of Spring’ (Analog Nov 2001)
- Rick Shelley’s ‘First Contact National Monument’ (Analog Dec 2001)
- On Spec:
- Gary Archambault’s ‘The Blue, Blue Grass of Home’ (#45)
- James Van Pelt’s ‘Father’s Dragon’ (#46)
- Janine Cross’ ‘Flushed With Success’ (#46)
But, all in all, not a bad collection!